Welcome back Meta-Traders.Check back Sunday for an update and have a great weekend.
Join me on my on going journey toward financial independence trading stocks, options and Forex through the TradeStation platform.
Welcome back Meta-Traders.Check back Sunday for an update and have a great weekend.
Welcome back Meta-Traders.Here are the results of a back to live test consistency check on my own Expert Advisor called FX-Regression. Since the system back-tests fairly well, the goal is to determine if these back tests are somehow flawed and will not be reflected in actual trading.
For the period of January 12, 2011 (when I started trading live) through March 31, 2011, here are the results:
- Results of trades was plus $41.71 or about +4.7
- Total Net due to Interest roll was minus $3.19
- Net P&L was plus $38.52 or about +3.5%
The period does not include the trade opened on 3/31 and 4/1 which resulted in a loss and put the account back into the negative. Attempts to reconcile the actual and live trades ran into these challenges:
- Back tests run on Forex.com showed a high number of chart mismatch errors, so the results had to be discarded
- Back tests were derived from Alpari US instead
- We had a clock change due to daylight savings. For live trading, I changed the start time for the trade to keep the start time consistent with US Eastern time, caused a shift in start time on the server that was not properly reflected in the back test.
Overall, the back tests showed the account down $60 or minus 6% for the test period. A detailed comparison of the trades for each symbol showed the following:
- EUR/USD took 40 live trades an about 30 of them were consistent the back test
- USD/CHF took 29 live trades and only 12 were consistent with the back test
- USD/CAD took 24 live trades and only 9 were constent with the back test
For cases where the live trading and back test didn't check out, we saw nearly every possible situation:
- Profits in live trading that showed as losses in the back test
- Profits in live trading that were missing altogether from the back test
- Losses in live trading showing as profits in the back test
- Losses in live trading that were missing altogether from the back test
Conclusions are difficult to come by with such a jumble of data. The fact that I got the closest results with EUR/USD show the spread-senstive nature of this trading system. Back tests used a fixed spread of 2 pips for EUR/USD, 3.5 for USD/CHF and 5.0 for USD/CAD set with the Asirikuy back test setting program. Differences between these values would cause the exact symptoms were are seeing:Overall conclusion is that back tests with this system bear at best a sketchy resemblance with live test results. Larger SP and TL values would reduce the size of the error cases not by eliminating the underlying problems - but by reducing the number of times they occur. Actual trading results - at least for the test period - were better that back test results. Whether this conclusion pans out for the rest of the year remains to be seen.
Have a great week all.
Welcome back Meta-Traders.The first quarter 2011 came to a close this week. On the weather front, the spring lamb still hasn't arrived and the winter lion still remains well in charge. With pool season a mere 6 weeks away, spring and summer better get a get a move on!
Global equity markets continued their gravity defying climb. With a healthy dose of end-of-month and end-of-quarter window dressing, many stocks recovered nicely from their March 16th lows and ralled back nicely. As is stands now, the S&P 500 is just about 1% off the highs set back on Feb 18th.
The fly in the ointment of the global economic recovery continues to be risking energy prices. Crude oil prices got out to a 30-month high and was up nearly 2.5% for the week and up 27% from a year ago. I'm holding a small amount of ETF USO as an energy price hedge but overall i'm underinvested in energy.
My week in currencies was less than spectacular. I reversed my short in USD/JPY and went long on Sunday evening. I took a small profit on the long rather than letting it run which was clearly a mistake since I could have picked up abou 250 pips had I just stuck with it. Also, I manually closed out some losing trades in Sunday gap trader DCT. So overall, I was not in good trading form with this account and as a result Megadroid Live lost about on half of 1% on the week.
As for the robots, the week's winner was Atipaq Full Portfolio which picked up about 2.5% on the week. Even better, it went out with about 318 pips in open profits on a trio of NZD/USD long trades!
Every other live acount was down so let's get through them quickly.
Atinalla No1 Live lost about 1% for the week but went out long EUR/USD with an open profit of about 75 pips.
FX-Regression sliced through its recent profits losing about 4% for the week and went out down -1.77% year to date. Now that the quarter is over, I need to do a live / back-test consistency check. Perhaps I can get that out tomorrow.
Atinalla FE was idle for the week.
Atinalla No3 lost about 1.8% on the week, but went into the weekend with 74 pips in open profits.
Atinalla No4 lost about 0.8% for the week and seems doomed to continue to lose money.
Demo account COATL EUR Centered Portfolio but went out with about -451 pips in open losses.
Finally a quick note to my friend JT since his blog no longer accepts comments. The Zulu platform encourages unsound trading tactics and all the newbie users are drawn to these signal providers like bees to honey. Eventually, the provider goes off the cliff and takes down all the newbie users and takes away their money. I should know since I was once one of them.
That's it for now. Enjoy your weekend and get some rest.
Welcome back Meta-Traders.
Welcome back Meta-Traders.As if that weren't enough, it the system went into the weekend with over 100 pips in open profits. Thank you Daniel Fernandez!
Next up was Atinalla #1 Live which picked up just under 1% for the week but went into the weekend with about 58 pips in open profits.
Next up was Atinalla #3 Live which was down about 0.8% for the week and went out with about 47 pips in open losses.
My own EA FX-Regression Live gyrated around the zero point.
Next up is Atinalla FE Live went to a new equity low early in the week down about -6.5% but came back somewhat later in the week and went into the weekend with an open profit in a long EUR/USD position.
Finally Atinalla #4 SM Live was down fractionally for the week but went out long with about 50 pips in open profits.
One last word demo account COATL EUR Centered Portfolio had a spectacular week picking up 11.59% for the week. Even more impressive is that it went out with an astounding 2700 pips in open profits! That's an incredible performance and pretty unbelievable for a forex robot. Keep up the great work Daniel Fernandez!
That's all for now and let's keep the brave people of Japan in our thoughts ..
Welcome back Meta-Traders.
Welcome back Meta-Traders.